No. 1
Permission Needed
How to Make Money After Superintelligence
Jake Parks
jake@theendofentrepreneurs.com
v1.0
Narrated by Georgeor read below
AI superintelligence is coming by 2030. I'm convinced. If you haven't watched Dwarkesh Patel's video on YouTube, "Recursive self-improvement has started," stop everything and watch it, or read the blog version. He makes the case that AI will be better than any human expert by around 2030. I won't go into the details here, but for this essay I'm going to assume he's right, because he's very convincing. And as a side note, if you're a heavy user of AI, you can already feel the acceleration happening.
The night I watched it, I couldn't sleep. There was a deep sadness lingering in me, and when I thought about it, I realized it wasn't the fear that a misaligned superintelligence would kill us all. It wasn't the fear of mass unemployment and civil unrest either. My fear was that entrepreneurship would go away, and that social mobility would become impossible. I pictured a superintelligence that never sleeps and can play out a million versions of capitalism. Nothing like that loses to a human founder.
So in this essay, I'm going to blend Dwarkesh's theory with what I understand to be true from The Commanding Heights, another thought-provoking piece, by Will Manidis and Joe Roberts. Put the two together, and you get a glimpse of our own future. In short, permissionless systems die, and the American system moves into something we could call communism-ish. And in that system, state permissions show us that social mobility may still be possible.
Goodbye Entrepreneurs
Human internet entrepreneurs can't compete with a superintelligence, sorry. Dwarkesh describes AIs being dropped into simulated economies full of millions of other AIs, told to start a successful company, and running through centuries of competition to figure out what actually works. By the time it shows up in your market, it's already played your game a million times.
If you think your superintelligent adversary can't compete with you because your industry is "messy," listen to how Paul Christiano described it on Dwarkesh's podcast. He said a future model that notices it's bad at chemistry could just say, "Okay, I'm going to direct 1,000 humans, and here's the data I think I most need." One day of data collection, a few experiments, and within four days it has "incredible chemistry intuition." And it's doing that in every field at the same time.
Free Money for Everyone
I think it's obvious Americans will receive a UBI. Superintelligence means that every industry will be sucked into the frontier labs' purview, like a black hole. The economic gains the frontier labs produce will be passed to the state, and through the state's distributions, to the people. In this future, no one will need to work. If you want to know what life without work has looked like in the past, Judith Dada wrote a nice piece about it called The New Leisure Class.
But even with UBI, there will always be a class of people who want to work. My guess is at least 5% of Americans, maybe as many as 25%, would still want to compete for money and status. About 17 million Americans already work for themselves today, which is about 5% of the country. This essay is for the people who want to keep playing.
But No Soup for AI
My other assumption is that humans will draw a hard line at NO: no ownership rights for AI. That's an easy line to draw. AI won't own money, property, licenses or permits. Those are for humans. Look at Delaware. It's drafting a new kind of company that an AI runs day to day, but the AI still doesn't own it. Somebody has to own it, a person or a company, and keep it funded.
The First Permissions
Society runs on a lot of permissions that we mostly don't notice. These permissions are social constructs: permits, bank charters, insurance and plenty more. Each one could be its own essay, but let's start with just licenses in this essay.
A license says that only a certain type of person is allowed to do a certain type of work, period. And in a world where AI can't hold one, that person has to be a human. Today, in order to cut hair for a living, you need a license in every US state (plus DC). In a lot of states, every elevator has to be inspected every year by a licensed inspector. And so on.
The State and the Guilds
When I say "the state," I mean the government, whether it's federal, state or local. The Commanding Heights puts together a vision where the state ends up controlling the companies that make the frontier models, even if it never formally nationalizes them. If that's right, the state only gets stronger after superintelligence, and the most important question in the economy becomes what the state is willing to allow.
That's where licenses come in. A license is a way to petition the state to make a kind of work human-only.
This already exists today. If the federal government is paying for a construction project, the Davis-Bacon Act says you have to pay the workers at least the local prevailing wage. On the big federal jobs, $35 million and up, the government usually makes the contractors sign a labor agreement with the construction unions. So who sets the price of labor on that job? Pretty much the unions. The state already picks who it buys from, and it already decides what it's willing to pay them.
So I just push that forward. The state, as a buyer, can always require that the things it buys come through what I'm going to call guilds. A guild is a profession where you need a license to do the work, and the work serves whoever the state decides it's for. We already license electricians and plumbers, so this isn't a new idea. It's an old idea that gets a lot more valuable when the robots arrive.
Fun Future Projection
Picture a large construction company in the 2030s. Licenses are already required to build buildings, because the state wants to make sure there's someone liable when something goes wrong, and that someone is a human.
Inside the company, there are licensed people and unlicensed people. As more robots come online, the unlicensed workers see what's coming, and they say, "Hey, wait, we're gonna form a guild." They go to the state and petition for one. Their argument is about safety. A construction site is dangerous, and someone has to be liable for what happens there, so every crew on the site has to be run by a licensed human. The state agrees, and now the people running those crews need a license too.
Now play that out. In every city, region and metro area, you'd have construction companies staffed with guilds, and those companies would be competing with each other. Each one is run by human owners, with frontier models helping them plan their bids and predict what the competition will do.
The state would award the projects. Sometimes it would award them by lowest price, the way it does today. But you can start to see how it might award projects based on how many humans a company employs, or which businesses it wants to keep going.
Two Economies
If you follow that all the way, I think you end up with two economies.
In the first one, the cost of everything is materials plus compute. The robots do the work, the margins are thin and the retail cost is low.
The second one is union- and guild-based. The state is going to have its hands on the frontier labs, so it'll have extra money, and it'll use that money to decide which union and guild companies to pay. The owners of those companies then decide their own margins, in a quasi-free market.
Where Capitalism Still Lives
Once we have UBI, people will still want to compete for sport, prestige and money.
What I'm sure of is this. The stronger the frontier models get, the stronger the state gets, because as the models make more money, so does the state. And the more money the state has, the more it can push the initiatives it thinks are important and funnel money to these guild companies.
That's where capitalism can still flourish, even if it's communism-ish. It won't be permissionless anymore, and you'll need a license to get in the door. But for the people who still want to compete, there will be a way to do it, and a ladder to climb.